Showing posts with label Middle-East. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Middle-East. Show all posts

Monday, September 21, 2026

There is no "Genocide" in Gaza

 

(Photo: Tel Aviv demonstration with families and supporters for the release
 of the Israeli hostages in Gaza)

THERE IS NO "GENOCIDE" IN GAZA

                The bombardment from all sides against Israel and the current war in Gaza has reached a fever pitch. A war that began on October 7 with the Palestinians’ murderous attack on Israeli civilians has now turned its head against those who have been offering peace.

                For almost 80 years, the Palestinians—only named as such in 1964, with the adoption of their charter—have refused to accept Israel’s existence. Time and again, they have launched wars and, failing to achieve their goal of annihilating Israel, have cried out about injustice while refusing to take responsibility for the consequences for their own people and to accept Israel’s peace offerings. For them, peace is not an alternative to the suffering of their population.

                These are the people who are not separate from Hamas because they are the ones who built an immense network of tunnels, indoctrinated their children to hate and kill Jews, and, most recently, aided in hiding many of the Israeli hostages. They are the ones who streamed into the battered Israeli villages to pillage and loot. They are the ones who, according to polls, supported the October 7 attack.

                Generation after generation, these are young people whose parents put guns in their hands at the age of five and send them to Hamas after-school programs, whose mothers express hope and pride that their children would die as martyrs. They are the underage terrorists who fill the ranks of Hamas.

                You may think of it in another way: In Nazi Germany, there were Germans who risked their entire families in order to save a single Jew. Yet not one Palestinian tried to do something for the hostages, even after Israel offered $5,000,000 and a safe passage out of Gaza to any informant and their family for information that would lead to a hostage.

                Through the international criticism of Israel’s lingering war in Gaza—and especially the blood libel of genocide thrown around so freely and frequently that it has become, in many minds, “a fact”—there has been little attempt to understand the conflict from the point of view of traumatized Israelis.

                Let’s take a look internally at what Israelis think about the war, using the lens of the upcoming Israeli election on October 27. If the war in Gaza represents a humanitarian crisis of starvation and the intentional killing of Palestinians, wouldn’t this argument be at the top of the political campaigns of those opposing Netanyahu?

                Of all five leading candidates opposing Netanyahu—all good guys, mostly with military backgrounds—not one has objected to the existential war against Hamas that began on October 7, but which has a long history going back decades.

                Not one is accusing the government of genocide. 

                To make this easy to understand, I asked AI to summarize the positions of each of these candidates so that my friends can grasp the common denominator: all of them—even those on the left—understand that there is a ruthless enemy that poses an existential threat to Israel. They differ greatly over how to move forward.

                Here it is:

                Israel’s next Knesset election is scheduled for October 27, 2026. The opposition is unusually broad ideologically: it includes right-wing, centrist, and left-wing figures. That is particularly important when looking at Gaza, because opposing Netanyahu does not necessarily mean opposing his basic war objectives.

                Based on the latest polling and reporting, the five most significant anti-Netanyahu contenders/groups are Gadi Eisenkot, Naftali Bennett, Yair Lapid, Yair Golan, and Avigdor Lieberman. Reuters identifies these as the principal rival camps.

The candidates’ Positions on the Gaza war

                Gadi Eisenkot

                Hawkish, but wants a different strategy. He argues Netanyahu has failed because Hamas remains in power. Eisenkot supports replacing Hamas with another governing structure, including potentially a Palestinian technocratic administration, while maintaining Israeli security control/a security corridor. He favors using diplomacy alongside military pressure and is open to phased reconstruction tied to disarmament. He does not support a Palestinian state in the near or medium term.

                Naftali Bennett

                Very hawkish. Bennett says his Gaza policy is fundamentally different from Netanyahu’s because he favors a much more aggressive “zero tolerance” security policy. He has criticized Netanyahu for allowing Hamas to rebuild and has opposed Palestinian statehood. On Gaza, he is not advocating an Israeli withdrawal or a peace settlement; his emphasis is eliminating Hamas as a military threat.

                Yair Lapid

                Hawkish on Hamas, but more diplomatic. Lapid says Israel should not have ended up in the current situation in Gaza and argues that Egypt should become the principal outside power managing Gaza. He wants Hamas removed from power and disarmed, but believes Israel should combine military pressure with diplomacy, Egyptian involvement and reconstruction. He has also criticized the Netanyahu government’s handling of Palestinian civilians and Gaza’s humanitarian situation.

                Yair Golan

                Most explicitly oriented toward a political/diplomatic restructuring of Gaza. Golan proposes ending Hamas rule and replacing it with a Palestinian technocratic government, with Arab and international involvement. His plan incorporates the U.S.-backed Gaza roadmap, phased reconstruction in areas cleared of Hamas, international supervision and pressure on Hamas to disarm. Unlike Bennett and Eisenkot, Golan has expressed conditional support in principle for a demilitarized Palestinian state as part of a regional agreement, although he says the issue is not currently ripe for implementation.

                Avigdor Lieberman

                Very hawkish toward Hamas. Lieberman has long argued that Israel was too soft toward Hamas and has called for dismantling Hamas’s rule. In 2026 he has criticized Netanyahu for failing to defeat Hamas and has said that, after the election, Hamas should be disarmed and dismantled. He has also criticized ceasefire arrangements when he believes they leave Hamas intact.

                None of these five is campaigning on simply ending Israel’s military conflict with Hamas and withdrawing from Gaza. Even the more dovish opposition figures generally say that Hamas must lose its military and governing capacity and that Israel must retain substantial security guarantees. Reuters notes that the opposition’s criticism has largely been about how Netanyahu has conducted the war and what political outcome he has achieved, rather than rejecting Israel’s use of force against Hamas.

                The meaningful differences are more about what happens after Hamas:

                * Bennett: security first; strongly opposed to Palestinian statehood.

                * Eisenkot: Hamas must go, but military pressure needs to be combined with diplomacy and a workable post-Hamas administration.

                * Lieberman: very hard line against Hamas; emphasizes defeating and dismantling it.

                * Lapid: Hamas must go, but Egypt should play the central role in administering Gaza and facilitating reconstruction.

                * Golan: the clearest advocate of an internationally/Arab-supported Palestinian technocratic alternative to Hamas, with a possible eventual political horizon for Palestinian statehood.

                (Bennett and Lapid are running together on the “Beyachad/Together” ticket, so their Gaza policies should be understood as a joint political project, even though their personal histories and ideological emphases differ).

                Back to me, Talia.

                What is not reflected in the above is that the huge criticism against Netanyahu is about internal affairs that range from his judicial reform, corruption of the ultra-Orthodox, and the rule of the far-right ideology. I'm not getting into this now, but I just want to add it as a perspective that when I and tens of thousands of Israelis like me who live abroad will fly to Israel to vote on October 27 (there is no voting by mail) it will be because of the poor, corrupt, and egomaniac leadership.

                I hope that this post will help you understand that Israel is at war with a murderous enemy, whose ranks a filled by their own people who do not seek peace with Jews and Israel. The Palestinians, starting with their 1964 charter committing to the destruction of Israel, are the ones screaming publicly at every opportunity their genocidal intentions against the Jews.

Golda Meir had said, “If the Arabs lay their arms, there will be peace. If Israel lays down its arms, there will be no Israel.”

                               

 


 

Thursday, November 7, 2024

Israel--A Year after October 7

 

(This is a footnote to my November 2024 newsletter)

 My summary of a complex situation in Israel

 




My phone screen flashes every Israeli news channel in Hebrew and US news in English. My soul is there, in Israel, when sirens go off all day in multiple villages and cities and when the trauma of a country in war deepens.

The majority of Israelis were for fighting Hamas and for chasing them throughout Gaza until they are eliminated. It was never a retaliation, but a defense against a repeat of October 7, which Hamas promised was only "a dress rehearsal." So many have given their lives on both sides as this war is still to be won, while tortured hostages remain imprisoned. Now the mood in Israel has shifted, and many Israelis make the hostages' release a priority over eliminating Hamas. They are not against the war that daily costs the lives of the best of Israeli men and has destroyed the country's flourishing economy, because there is no choice when attacked from all sides. The all-mighty Iran has no territorial disputes with Israel, nor does it care for the Palestinians. It merely wants Israel wiped out.

           While the world's eyes were focused solely on the Gaza war--ignoring human misery in other 30 hot spots around the globe--since October 7, 2023, the Galilee (northern Israel) has been under Hezbollah bombardment. Over 100,000 Israelis had to abandon their homes and farms while the government attempted to avoid formally calling it a war--until it could ignore it no more.

Some of you have asked me for a reliable sources about the situation. Here are some suggestions: Middle East Forum, MEMRI, CAMERA, Palestinian Media Watch, Israenet.org, UN Watch, and AIPAC, CIJA, Jewish Virtual Library, and HonestReporting.

           In the meantime, the highly unpopular PM Netanyahu is holding on to his fragile government by capitulating to the tyranny of the ultra-Orthodox who do not serve in the military. Tens of thousands lifelong yeshiva students with large families (ten children or more is the norm) live off government largess. The gap between those who give everything and those who only take has never been so wide. Therefore, when you hear about huge demonstrations against Netanyahu, those are fueled by anger over this social injustice--and by the gut-piercing angst over the hostages.

The country is fighting an existential war for survival, while being torn from within. Yet, the more Israelis face these challenges, the more they need us to support them, to let them know that they are not alone.



 

Saturday, April 13, 2024

A Letter to a Peace-Loving Humanitarian

 

The following letter is my response to an activist who tried to recruit me for his cause of "Strategy of Nonviolence, For the Children." 




Dear Mr. Sheldon,

          Thank you for writing to me, as it gives me the opportunity to explain that despite your good intentions, your initiative is, unfortunately, misguided, if not outright hateful and fateful.

            The idea of an enforced cease-fire between Israel, a democratic state and Hamas, a terror organization, means only one thing: the terror organization will continue to pursue its declared goal of eliminating Israel and killing its entire population. You will be prohibiting Israel from responding to murderous attacks on her populace. Not only has Hamas been showering Israel for years with thousands of daily missiles aimed at the civilian population—which had not prompted you to announce an initiative to force Hamas to stop—but Hamas broke every ceasefire ever negotiated with them. 

            How is your forcing Israel to stop fighting Hamas promotes peace? All it will do is strengthen and legitimize the terror organization which has declared that October 7th was only “a rehearsal” and that it would continue to repeat these barbaric atrocities to eliminate Israel. 

            Why isn’t your first call to demand that Hamas return the hostages? Why doesn’t your “strategy for non-violence” begin with a demand that Hamas surrender and stop using the Palestinian population as human shields? 

            You’ve had plenty of chances to take initiative. For years you could have demanded that US and Europe stop funneling money through the UN to perpetuate indefinite refugee status of the Palestinians. Tens of millions of displaces people after WWII had long been resettled. None is claiming to be a refugee three generations later, even while living in other countries, where they have made a home. Definitely not the Jews, who’d lost more than any other ethnic or national group. 

            Why haven’t you demanded—or demanding now—that the Arab countries who had exploited these people in 1948 with their murderous intention of annihilating Israel, now take responsibility for the results? None has ever offered to absorb a single Palestinian family. In fact, most have enacted apartheid laws against the Palestinians’ entry and integration. Unlike Israel which had provided employment to tens of thousands Gazans daily, Egypt had sealed its border with Gaza. 

            For your information, in 1948, the population in Gaza was about 300,000. It has since swelled to 2 million. In 2030, Gaza's population is projected to reach 3 million. Yes, in only six years it will grow by 50%. Whose responsibility is that? Where do you want these people to live? 

            Asking the question differently: What should the world do for this population you so care about when it grows additional 50% six years later, reaching over 4 million? Taking over modern-day Israel and killing the Jews living there? 

            Why haven’t you cried out your indignation when, for 75 years, UNRWA-sponsored schools taught children not only how to hate Jews, but how to use weapons to kill them, viewing Jews as less than humans? Why haven’t you cried out when you heard time and again that Palestinian parents’ greatest hopes for their children were for them to become “martyrs” who kill Jews? Where was your initiative when your tax dollars paid for militant summer camps teaching Palestinian children to kill? 

            What you now learn about children killed in Gaza, is that thousands of them are teenagers fighting as terrorists they had been indoctrinated to become. What was your strategy of non-violence for these children then, and what is it now? 

            The atrocities visited upon the Jews on October 7th were rarely recorded in their intensity, barbarism, and severity in modern human history. Yet, your past silence allowed it to happen. Your future “initiative” will make such final genocide of Jews in Israel a fact. 

            Where are your Christian sensitivities and benevolence when you accept the beheading of Jewish babies in their cribs and the lopping off of women’s breasts? What about shooting nails into women’s vaginas? How about gouging out a father’s eyes in front of his children, or burning a whole family alive in their home? 

            This will be the fate of the Jews under the repeat torture and massacre that your “non-violent cease-fire” will bring.  

            Cease-fire does not mean non-violence as you state. It means increased violence against the Jews of Israel. That is exactly what you preach. 

            Yes, Mr. Sheldon, there is a lot of work to be done, but the first of it is to support Israel which is under constant, unrelenting attack by terrorists whose actions against both populations—Israelis and Palestinians—are accepted by you and by other misguided good souls cheered on by mobs of anti-Semites. The cost of the war to both sides is enormous, but stopping it before it achieves its ultimate goal of eliminating Hamas only means the end of Israel, while giving legitimacy to a terror organization.  

            You can help stop the war. When you present your views to your list of misguided supporters and to the UN Secretary-General, please demand that the onus for achieving peace is on the world to stop terrorism. Demand Hamas’s unconditional surrender, just as ISIS was defeated. Demand the immediate return the hostages—and the end the war on Israel. 

            Please do not shift your gaze, for one minute, from the one entity that can stop the war: Hamas. 

            By doing so you’ll be freeing the Palestinian people, who may not be enamored of Israel, but whose suffering is wholly the result of years of oppression, corruption, and savagery by Hamas. Without Hamas, the war with Israel will stop and, with time and a different educational approach, these people may begin to have a vision of peace and prosperity. 

            It’s a simple as that. 

            Then you may turn to the world to fix the evil of UNRWA and the barbaric teaching of hate under its sponsorship. You may see future funding of Gaza not exploited for the construction of war-designated tunnels, but for the civilian purposes of building a society whose institutions carry out a vision of economic growth. 

            Mr. Sheldon, I urge you to rechannel your energy to support Israel, not to make her the victim of another Holocaust, as Hamas promises to do.

 Shalom,

Talia Carner

www.TaliaCarner.com 


Talia Carner is a novelist with HarperCollins. Her latest novel is THE BOY WITH THE STAR TATTOO. 

Sharon, an assistant to an Israeli naval officer stationed in Normandy, France, is intent on tracing his orphan roots to the French village from where he had been rescued post-WWII. When she identifies the mother who had tragically lost him, Sharon is unprepared for the shock of her discovery.